Lasik Vs PRK Vs Smile Vs ICL

The days of dependence on blurry glasses or uncomfortable contact lenses are fading. Thanks to innovative ophthalmic advancements, achieving clear vision now offers several minimally invasive, exciting options. LASIK, PRK, SMILE, and ICL are at the forefront of this revolution, each catering to different needs and promising sharper sights for life. But with this abundance of choices, the decision can feel overwhelming.

This comprehensive guide unveils the secrets of these four vision correction stars, equipping you with the knowledge to make an informed and confident choice for your eyes.


The Players on the Field

  • LASIK (Laser-Assisted In Situ Keratomileusis):
    The veteran, LASIK is a well-established procedure involving creating an 18-20 mm corneal flap using a blade or a laser, which is lifted to expose the underlying tissue, reshaping the underlying tissue with an excimer laser to correct refractive errors and repositioning the flap.
  • PRK (Photorefractive Keratectomy):
    The minimalist, PRK skips the flap creation and removes the corneal epithelium (outer layer) before the laser reshapes the cornea. The epithelium regenerates naturally after the procedure.
  • SMILE (Small Incision Lenticule Extraction):
    The new kid on the block, SMILE uses a femtosecond laser to create a 2-4 mm micro-incision and delicately extract a lenticule from within the cornea, reshaping it for perfect vision. Its flapless, minimally invasive keyhole nature is ideal for active individuals and those with dry eye concerns.
  • ICL (Implantable Collamer Lens):
    The game-changer, ICL bypasses the cornea altogether. This procedure involves implanting a specially designed lens behind the iris and in front of the natural lens through a small corneal incision, correcting refractive errors without altering the corneal’s shape.


The Scoreboard: Key Differences That Matter

  • Procedure:
    LASIK and ICL are the most invasive due to flap creation or lens implantation, while PRK and SMILE are minimally invasive.


  • Recovery:
    LASIK and ICL offer the quickest recovery, with many patients experiencing improved vision within a day or two for LASIK and within a few days for ICL. On the other hand, PRK requires more time due to surface healing, often taking 2-3 weeks. SMILE, similar to LASIK, provides visual recovery in 3-4 days.


  • Corneal Thickness Criteria:
    For LASIK, it is recommended to have a central corneal thickness of at least 500 microns. Similarly, for PRK, a thickness of at least 485 microns is preferred. In the case of SMILE, the ideal central corneal thickness should be at least 550 microns. ICL does not have specific central corneal thickness requirements, as it is not a corneal-based procedure.


  • Suitability:
    LASIK is a great option for individuals with mild to moderate nearsightedness, farsightedness, and astigmatism. However, it is not recommended for those with thin corneas or who suffer from dry eye syndrome, as well as certain eye conditions.

On the other hand, PRK is a suitable choice for individuals with high myopia, thin corneas, and irregular corneal surfaces. It is also beneficial for those who are not eligible for LASIK. PRK may be preferred by contact sports enthusiasts due to the absence of a flap.
For individuals with myopia and astigmatism, SMILE is a suitable alternative. It is particularly useful for those who are not eligible for LASIK or PRK. Additionally, individuals engaged in contact sports or professions with an increased risk of eye injury will find this procedure especially beneficial. However, it is important to note that SMILE is not suitable for treating hyperopia or those with thinner corneas.

ICL shines as an excellent option for moderate to high refractive errors, particularly for individuals with very thin corneas or dry eyes. It may serve as an alternative for those who are not eligible for corneal procedures.


  • Flap-Related Complications:

Only LASIK has the potential for flap-related issues like dislodgement, wrinkles, or inflammation. The other procedures eliminate this risk.


  • Dry Eyes:
    LASIK is more likely to cause dry eyes after the procedure due to the creation of the cornea flap. This poses a risk of permanent LASIK-induced dry eyes. On the other hand, PRK and SMILE have a lower likelihood of causing dry eyes, while ICL is highly unlikely to result in dry eyes since it does not involve the cornea and leaves the nerve endings untouched.


  • Discomfort:
    PRK might involve some initial discomfort during healing due to the healing of the corneal surface, while the others generally cause minimal to no discomfort.


  • Cost:
    The cost can vary depending on your location, surgeon’s experience, and the specific procedure chosen. Generally, ICL tends to be the most expensive, followed by SMILE and LASIK, with PRK being the most cost-effective.


Beyond the Stats

But it’s not just about numbers. Each procedure has its own appeal:

  • LASIK:
    If convenience is your priority, LASIK offers the fastest recovery and a well-established track record.
  • PRK:
    For those with thin corneas or a passion for rough-and-tumble activities, PRK’s flapless nature and potentially reduced dry eye risk are strong contenders.
  • SMILE:
    If minimal invasiveness, quick recovery, and flap-free peace of mind are your top concerns, SMILE’s cutting-edge approach might be the perfect fit.
  • ICL:
    And for individuals with high refractive errors, thin corneas, or dry eyes who seek a permanent solution, ICL’s versatility and independence from the cornea stand out.


The Winning Play

When it comes to choosing the right solution for your eyes, it’s a personal journey best taken alongside your trusted ophthalmologist. They will evaluate your unique needs, considering factors such as your refractive error, corneal thickness, lifestyle, and medical history, to recommend the most suitable procedure.

Remember, this decision isn’t about simply following the crowd or seeking the quickest recovery. It’s about finding a long-term solution that fits your individual vision requirements and ensures ongoing eye health and well-being.

Approach this journey with a clear perspective, equipped with knowledge and empowered by the freedom of choice. With numerous innovative options available, achieving crystal-clear vision is as close as a laser beam, a gentle touch, or a precisely placed lens.
Embrace the possibilities and let your newfound vision lead you to a world of limitless clarity and adventure!

Bonus Tip: Inquire your ophthalmologist about the specifics of each procedure, such as success rates, potential risks, and long-term outcomes. Don’t hesitate to gather all the information you need for a well-informed decision.


Book an Appointment

Contact Us For A Free Lasik Consultation

We promise to only answer your queries and to not bother you with any sales calls or texts.
Open chat
💬 Need Help ?
Hello 🙂 🙏 ,
Can we help you?